Choosing the right website platform is a bit like choosing the right tool to renovate your home. If you're going to open up the kitchen and redesign everything, you want a toolset that's not just functional, but also aligned with how you naturally work. Similarly, the platform you choose to build your website isn't simply about templates and price; it's about long-term flexibility, ease of updates, SEO, integrations, and more. For many small business owners I work with here at Zach Sean Web Design, especially those in Franklin and surrounding areas, this decision feels weighty—and it should.
A common comparison I hear from clients sounds like this: “Should I build my site on Webflow… or should I stick with Squarespace?” And it’s a great question. Both are modern, drag-and-drop platforms vying for the attention of entrepreneurs, creatives, service providers, and stores. Yet their philosophies, ecosystem, and scalability tell very different stories once you get into them. This post will break down Webflow vs. Squarespace for small business owners not just from a feature standpoint, but also from a business and emotional one—because a website isn't just tech. It's brand psychology, flexibility, marketing, and client experience all wrapped into one.
Webflow positions itself as a platform for designers who want full control—without relying on developers. It borrows heavily from the structure of coding (HTML, CSS, even some JS), but distills it into a visual builder. The result: near-unlimited layout freedom with the visual intensity of traditional development. You don’t use Webflow like a template shop. You build with it like you’re constructing something custom from foundation to chimney.
This makes it ideal for businesses that have (or want) a more expressive or strategic approach to web presence. For example, I recently helped a boutique landscaping company in Brentwood redesign its site with subtle animations, dynamically filtered galleries, and a fully customized backend for editing recurring project features. That wouldn't have been possible in Squarespace without major handcoding or workarounds.
Squarespace, on the other hand, has always leaned into elegance with simplicity. It’s positioned as the Apple of web design platforms: beautiful templates out-of-the-box, excellent user interface, and easy-to-use editing tools. This makes it great for newer businesses that need to launch quickly and stay minimal.
But here's the catch: design flexibility is limited unless you're comfortable with code. Even customization around things like button shapes or specific mobile layouts can get tricky. A health coach I worked with recently had hit a wall with Squarespace trying to integrate a course platform fluidly. The original site looked professional—but didn’t age well as the business needed more agility in UX and SEO customization.
If you've ever tried to maneuver a couch into an attic bedroom, you know there are limits to what can be done based on structural constraints. Webflow removes those kinds of barriers in web design. Designers and small business owners alike can build pages from the ground up—layer by layer—while choosing every color, font, grid, and break point.
For instance, when we redesigned a custom cabinetry website for a business near Nashville, the responsiveness across desktop, tablet, and phone wasn’t just an afterthought. We created breakpoints at custom widths to ensure their photo-heavy layouts looked good at any dimension—a level of detail web developers often save for huge-budget projects. In Webflow, this level of polish is realistically achievable for a $5k-$10k small business website build.
Squarespace doesn’t hand you blueprints—it gives you a model home. You can customize the paint color, furniture layout, maybe add a porch light or two. But knocking down structural elements? Not likely. This platform shines when you're working within a pretty small range of layout needs. If your brand concept is straightforward, that's often enough.
A Franklin-based wedding photographer I assisted last year loved her original her Squarespace portfolio. But, as her bookings expanded and she needed custom galleries sorted by wedding type, plus password-protected posts for clients, we hit a wall. Webflow—and even WordPress—offered those options more elegantly. But she stuck with Squarespace, hired a developer to write custom blocks, and lost the core simplicity she came for in the first place.
Webflow’s pricing is tiered based on number of pages, CMS collections, and teammates. You also pay for hosting. At first glance, that seems steep. But what you’re really buying into is a system built for longevity. No plugins to babysit. No version updates to manage. No third-party themes that break when the platform changes. Everything is self-contained.
A service provider in Murfreesboro who came to me with speed issues on her WordPress site moved to Webflow and got a +43% improvement in load speed, plus a fully custom-designed interface. She pays about $29/month in hosting now, but she’s not paying $400 every few months for someone to fix broken plugins. Over time, it nets out in her favor.
With Squarespace, you pay a flat monthly rate that bundles hosting, templates, scheduling tools (on higher tiers), optional email marketing, and analytics. For small businesses looking for all-in-one ease, this is a huge convenience. If budget is tight and you’d rather not piece together dozens of services, the platform feels like a godsend.
But the tradeoff often shows up when people scale. A yoga studio client of mine loved her original $25/month site. But once she started transitioning into remote classes and wanted to build member dashboards, integration with Zoom, and gated content, the limitations ballooned her third-party spending. Suddenly she needed MemberSpace and Zapier and a dozen Glide forms to make it work. That monthly $25 grew closer to $120+—still less than custom dev but not ideal for her needs.
Simplified SEO tools are a double-edged sword. Squarespace gives you clean URLs, built-in sitemaps, and nice-looking headings—but its fine-tuned metadata control, collection templating, and schema customization are lacking. If your business relies heavily on local SEO, blogs, or technical on-page optimization, you’ll top out quickly.
Webflow, by comparison, offers deep control: open graph settings per page, clean semantic HTML structure, custom alt text, manual schema injections, and even CMS-powered content that updates site-wide without manual reindexing. For multi-location franchises I’ve worked with, these details are vital for long-tail local search queries like “custom framing in Williamson County.”
One agency client who moved from Squarespace to Webflow saw organic traffic increase by 113% over six months. Why? We embedded JSON-LD structured data, optimized page loads, and spun up CMS-fueled case studies. None of that would have been efficient, or even possible, on Squarespace alone. For comparison, a handmade candle company on Squarespace asked me why their beautiful site wasn’t ranking. The answer came down to page headings (all H2s), no backlinks, and identical meta descriptions across pages. Visual appeal doesn’t equal algorithmic success.
For small business owners juggling fifty other tasks, the content editor is sacred territory. It needs to be logical, friendly, and low-maintenance. This is where Squarespace excels. You can drag a gallery block into a page, upload media, and type away—no development skills necessary. Even if someone hasn't touched their site in months, they can log in and tweak a few words without fear.
Compare that to a Webflow site: if not designed thoughtfully, the backend can feel overwhelming. Webflow’s native CMS is powerful but abstract. Clients sometimes panic when they see “Collection Item” or “Bind to Field.” I’ve learned to label everything humanely. One roofing service client now edits their testimonials inside an area labeled “Happy Customer Quotes — Add or Edit Here” instead of “CMS Collections.” That psychological shift matters.
If your business has repeatable content types—portfolio items, case studies, services by region—Webflow CMS is second to none. We built a CMS-powered real estate site where each property is automatically added to a gallery page, sorted by region, and updated with a single entry. The owner just drags in a new photo, selects a location, and it's done. Squarespace can’t replicate that without serious Frankenstein-ing (think: summary blocks inside loops with tags controlling filtering logic).
As your business grows, chances are your website’s job shifts. It stops being a digital brochure and starts becoming an experience hub—linking email automations, course dashboards, CRM tools, and structured workflows. Webflow offers an API-level integration flexibility that plays well with tools like Zapier, Airtable, Calendly, Mailchimp, Hubspot, and more.
This made all the difference for a consulting firm I worked with. We used Webflow’s CMS to manage articles and case studies, Airtable to handle internal editorial workflows, and Zapier to trigger social media alerts for featured content. It saved hours per week in manual posting and gave them a unified content loop that Squarespace couldn't hope to automate without major scripts or plugins.
But it’s not one-size-fits-all. A dog grooming business near Franklin was overwhelmed when I floated the idea of customizable workflows. They didn’t want a CMS or Airtable or even blog analytics—they just needed a clean gallery and basic booking. Squarespace delivered that in under two days. Their platform wins for lean teams who don’t intend to change the site often or add lead funnels in the future.
One element most non-designers underestimate is performance optimization. Webflow creates clean, lightweight code that loads quickly—critical for both user retention and SEO on mobile. Squarespace sites, conversely, sometimes use heavy scripts under the hood tied to design templates. That beautiful animation might cost you four seconds of load time—and that’s a bounce.
When we migrated an artist portfolio site from Squarespace to Webflow, their bounce rate dropped from 62% to 29%. What changed? A more streamlined layout, optimized image delivery, and deferred offscreen elements. These are subtle but cumulative benefits that show up only with direct experience.
Across hundreds of builds, consultations, and local SEO engagements, here’s what I’ve learned: Platform decisions are business decisions. Webflow is perfect for detailed customization, advanced SEO, and scaling a uniquely designed brand. Squarespace is ideal for lean teams, solo acts, and people who’d rather not ever think about code.
If you're a small business just starting out, with straightforward offerings, Squarespace will likely serve you well for at least a year or two. But if your vision goes beyond a digital brochure—if your brand strategy includes content marketing, or niche SEO targeting, workflow automation, or storytelling that doesn’t fit into a grid—Webflow offers a sturdy ecosystem to express all of that with few limits and tons of future-proofing.
Ultimately, I approach these questions in the same way I approach every client engagement: by first understanding the psychology, purpose, and growth plans behind the website. Not every business needs a sports car. Some just need a reliable scooter. But choose the one you can still drive comfortably two years from now—and ideally, one you’re proud to park in front of potential clients.
Copyright © Zach Sean Web Design
