There’s an unspoken weight small business owners carry when it comes to their online presence. Many of the folks I work with—whether they own a yoga studio down the street or a boutique law firm—know their business inside and out. But when Google announces another core algorithm update, it can feel like the digital rug's been pulled out from under them. The room spins. Rankings drop. The email inbox slowly starts to collect SEO cold pitches all promising to “fix” things. The panic is real.
I get it. I've been in that meeting where a business owner pulls up their most recent traffic report with a quiet sense of dread. That’s why I wanted to take a microscope to what we’ve seen happen with Google’s March 2024 Core Algorithm Update, and, more importantly, break down—in human terms—what this means for small businesses trying to show up, reach people, and grow sustainably.
Google’s core updates have this way of introducing changes that shift the soil under everyone’s feet. Sometimes it's subtle. Sometimes it's a minor earthquake. March 2024 was the latter. This was the third core update in less than a year, and according to Google itself, it was broader and more significant than previous ones.
In their official blog post here, Google emphasized a focus on reducing unhelpful content, improving quality signals, and increasing the visibility of what they call “hidden gems”—in other words, useful content from smaller sites that aren’t mass-producing SEO-optimized noise. Cue the collective exhale from independent creators—at least in theory.
But what does that actually mean for a small business in Franklin, TN, or anywhere else for that matter?
The update signaled a shift in how content is evaluated. Where previously, the SEO playbook often revolved around publishing frequently and optimizing for keywords, Google appears to be weighing in more heavily on authenticity, user intent, and depth over breadth.
If you're a small business pumping out a blog post every week just to fill the calendar, this update means it’s time to pause. It’s not about how much you write anymore. It’s about how genuinely helpful that content is to your ideal reader—something I’ve always tried to emphasize when helping clients build or revise their websites.
This update didn’t just nudge things. It shuffled the deck considerably. Sites that relied heavily on aggregated content, AI-generated filler, or generic SEO tactics were among the hardest hit according to third-party tracking tools like SEMrush Sensor and Rank Ranger.
Case Study 1: A Blog-Heavy Real Estate Firm
I worked with a mid-size real estate company that had been investing in weekly content like “Best Neighborhoods in Nashville” and “5 Tips for First-Time Buyers.” On the surface, these are solid topics. But their traffic dropped almost 28% after the March update.
We took a deeper look and realized their content, while SEO-optimized, was pretty surface level. There wasn’t much unique insight — nothing you couldn’t find rewritten in a dozen other places.
We pivoted. Rather than generic lists, we created content drawn from real client interactions: actual buyer questions, local regulation changes, construction updates, and live property reviews. Within two months, not only had traffic begun to rebound, but engagement doubled. People stayed longer and converted more.
Case Study 2: A One-Woman Therapy Practice
On the flip side, a solo therapist client of mine who had been sporadically blogging personal takes on burnout, emotional intelligence, and work-life balance saw a surprising 18% increase in organic traffic. She didn't write often, but when she did, it came from deep personal experience and resonated with her readers. Google’s update finally recognized the value of that.
In contrast, winners tended to produce content with intent and purpose.
An underlying theme in Google’s March 2024 update was refining how they define “helpfulness.” But that’s a loaded term. What’s helpful to one person may feel irrelevant to another. So let’s unpack a little more.
Google's aim appears to be closer to prioritizing content that demonstrates real-world expertise, satisfies searcher intent fully, and leaves the reader more informed, empowered, or inspired than when they clicked.
Let’s take an example. Suppose you own a small auto repair shop in Williamson County. Before, your blog might have been filled with posts like “Why Rotate Your Tires?” or “Top 5 Car Brands for 2024.” Helpful? Maybe. But also written by thousands of other shops.
One of my clients in that field pivoted to writing about job shadowing days with technicians, behind-the-scenes detail of specific repairs, and breakdown stories from real customers—always anonymized, of course. Those stories kept people not only on the page longer, but led to more direct service inquiries. That's the kind of depth that the current algorithm favors.
Google continues to evolve its E-E-A-T framework: Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness. It's not just what you write—it's how it's written, who's writing it, and whether your site architecture and design are reinforcing those ideas.
If your content is written by a person with actual experience—like me guiding businesses through full website rebuilds—that carries more weight now. And if that experience is communicated genuinely, it's gold.
Here’s where things get particularly interesting if you're a small business targeting a local market.
While the core update was largely global, we’ve also seen indirect shifts in how local search results behave. Google's Local Pack (that map-like preview you see on search) is influenced by different signals including proximity, recent reviews, and Google Business Profile updates. Yet content still plays a role.
In this new climate, adding authentic, community-grounded content is your competitive weapon.
A local coffee shop I worked with in Nashville had their website and Google listing fully optimized, but traffic plateaued. After the update, their local listing dipped, even though reviews remained steady.
The issue? Stale local relevance. We added a “Neighborhood News” section to their site where they posted quick updates about events, staff spotlights, and collaborations with nearby stores. Nothing fancy—just real community documentation. Result? A 22% uptick in local traffic in six weeks. They began appearing for more branded and local intent searches like “Franklin coffee near [landmark].”
I always say to clients: the structure of your website is like the plumbing of your house. If it’s faulty, nothing works. And yet, having great plumbing doesn’t mean your interior design automatically looks good. That’s where narrative architecture and tone come in.
This update didn’t abandon technical SEO—but it made it subordinate to overall page experience and user value.
But if you're nailing all of that and your content is bland or AI-driven filler, you're toast.
This is where tools like Hotjar or Microsoft Clarity can really make a difference. Use heat maps to see where users are actually engaging. Are people reading past the fold? Are they bouncing quickly? Do they pause over a story you included?
Yes, that’s SEO. Because it’s performance-based behavioral feedback. And it’s part of building trust with the search algorithm and your users.
Okay, so what do you actually do now? Here's a list of core strategies I’ve been implementing with clients post-update.
If I had to sum up the essence of the March 2024 update—and honestly, the modern SEO landscape as a whole—it's this:
Google seems to trust you more when you sound like a person than when you sound like a marketer.
For businesses like the ones I consult for, that’s actually encouraging. It levels the playing field. You don’t need a 1,000-post content strategy. You need a few right pieces that speak well, help deeply, and represent who you really are.
There’s something deeply human about good SEO in 2025. It's less about “gaming” Google and more about aligning with what your audience genuinely needs, trusts, and values. The March 2024 algorithm update reinforced this in a major way. And if you’re a small business owner who’s been treating your website like a static brochure, now is the time to view it as your most important storyteller.
It should engage, it should clarify, and it should care. SEO isn’t going away—but the way we approach it definitely needs to change. And the good news is, the businesses that win now are the ones who take the time to think, to understand their audience, and to communicate with clarity and care. That’s what builds trust, both with your users and with Google—and that’s how you build a search presence that lasts, no matter the update.
Copyright © Zach Sean Web Design
